Manaiakalani Reading Practice Intensive Course Day 3: Text Selection

Reflection on Homework from Day 2 – Creating Taskboards and Workspaces; Sharing Learning Intentions and Success Criteria

It was really interesting hearing the range of experiences from the other teachers in my breakout group, some of whom have been using taskboards for years, and others, like me, who are not familiar with it but very enthusiastic. I can see I am going to need to have a section in my Workspace for each group, so I can add in cards for the Learning Intentions and Success Criteria, etc.

Others in the group shared some amazing Taskboard (and another one) and Workspace examples, and I will also check out others linked on our course Mahi Tracker.

 

Dorothy – Shared Pedagogy and Kaupapa in the Context of Reading (including the ‘reading achievement challenge’)

Dorothy talked about the difficulties of having the perfect text in print but not available digitally. A few ways to address this are:

  • Voice Typing – get the learners themselves to transfer the text from print to digital
  • Google Keep – use the photo option to ‘rip’ the text
  • Use the Preview software on a Mac to rip the text
  • YouTube – Transcripts from any Youtube are readily available
  • Transcript easy to display as Subtitles

She introduced a range of online reading apps, stressing from the outset that reading apps are NOT a substitute for a real teacher. She also talked about the importance of tracking student work to ensure accountability, e.g. by using Mahi Trackers, embedding a Google Form on a class website, etc.

Dorothy also referred us to the recorded toolkit from Matt Goodwin: ChatGPT 101 for Teachers, which explains how to use ChatGPT to generate different versions of a text at specified reading levels.

So many tips and tools in Dorothy’s presentation that I want to follow up on!

 

Naomi – Choosing Appropriate Texts

Our focus today was the second pillar of the Reading Pillars of Practice: Plan to Use Diverse Texts. It is crucial to give our students regular opportunities to encounter different kinds of text, including running print text, and model how to unpack these.

We started by discussing how accessible the text is to the student. For optimal learning, readers should make no more than one error every 10 to 19 words (90 to 94% accuracy). So if we want to make sure that students access and understand content, the text needs to be at this level of accessibility.

Extra: It is important to note that fluency instruction should be with a text that a student can read at their independent level. It is at this level where students are able to practice on speed and expression rather than decoding. The chart below describes each reading level:

Instructional vs Independent Decoding Levels:

Independent  Relatively easy for the student to read 

(95 – 100% word accuracy).

Instructional  Challenging but manageable for the reader 

(90 – 94% word accuracy).

Frustration  Difficult text for the student to read 

(less than 90% word accuracy).

The new refreshed English curriculum signals a clear direction on reading. I am relieved to see that at least the reading for pleasure curriculum objective has survived the government review (which shamefully erased 36 mentions of Te Tiriti o Waitangi).

“The focus of this strand is on teaching students to decode, make meaning from, and think critically about text.

It also provides opportunities for them to develop a love of reading and to value the ways in which reading widely can enrich their lives. 

As text critics, students come to understand how language and texts work, enabling them to challenge texts. By exploring texts from New Zealand, the Pacific, and around the world, students gain insights into themselves and others.” (Te Mātaiaho, p.19)

An important consideration in our text choices is whether our students see themselves reflected in the texts they read (Mirrors) or are able to explore and experience the lives of others different from themselves (Windows). Texts provide a means for students from both majority and minority cultural groups to view and experience different worlds and lives, moving from one to another (through the Sliding Glass Doors).

Professor Rudine Sims Bishop, Professor Emerita, Ohio State University with the original analogy of windows and mirrors in relation to text diversity for readers. I found this so eloquent, and so ironic, given the current US drive to eradicate diversity and equity initiatives and remove diverse texts in schools, especially any texts with LGBTQI+ characters.

Naomi referred us to the text coverage page in our teacher workbooks, which gives a handy overview to check that diverse types of text are being used. This looks very familiar to me from previous Manaiakalani literacy PD when we were working on the T-Shaped Literacy model. I feel comfortable with this aspect as I always have tried to include diverse text types in my units.

 

Janet – Grouping Learners

How can we introduce the key learning ideas to a levelled grouping of learners. We want a range of texts that will be accessible for our learners, and not at the ‘Frustration’ level.

For mixed-ability groups, we need to consider ways to present information that will be accessible for all. For example, using lower-level, very accessible texts to present the main ideas/knowledge, and then a range of texts, including more complex ones which the high ability students can fly with. Using Accessible texts to convey key information reduces stress for the lower ability students and makes the ideas and content accessible to all.

 

Kiri – Selecting Texts for Groups

We looked at ways of sourcing texts, such as through JournalSurf, ARBs, the Connected series, etc.

When grouping students, consider reading levels, learning focus, but also student interest. I am thinking that our SchoolJoy programme will sort students by interest for me, which will help. We also need to bear in mind the importance of students aquiring vocabulary.

“It is estimated that to reach the goal of the 15 – 20 000 word vocabulary of a literate person, students must acquire a robust knowledge of about 700 words a year.”
(Beck et al, 1987)

Searching school journals on TKI will also provide a list of key vocabulary to teach.

 

Janet – Planning and Finding Texts for Your Groups

Some sources for texts are:

We were given some time to locate an ‘anchor text’ to use with the whole class. I will be teaching Elie Wiesel’s Holocaust memoir, Night, with my Y10 Humanities class next term. I looked for an introductory article about the Holocaust which could be used as an introduction to the unit. I found a journal article about the buttons Holocaust memorial project run in Wellington. Unfortunately, the article was not available online, so I will need to locate a copy before I can confirm if it is suitable to use as an anchor text.

 

Naomi – Text Sets

Multi-modal texts are important; Manaiakalani observations show that fewer non-fiction and student-selected texts are being used in our classrooms.

Questions for the teacher to ask:

  • Which text will help my learners access their prior knowledge, or build background knowledge best?
  • Which text will suit their current learning intention best?
  • Which text should I leave for further down the track as it will suit an upcoming learning intention better?
  • Which text will present a different perspective on the concept, once they have built their knowledge?

Things to take into account:

  • Ambitious learning outcomes
  • Purpose
  • Learning Intentions
  • Length of unit/concept/topic
  • Timetable
  • Engagement of learners
  • Richness of texts

We were also reminded to use the categories in the T-Shaped Literacy model:

 

Naomi – Strategy Builder: Summarising

Explicit teaching of processing and comprehension strategies involves:

  • Providing an explicit description of the selected strategy and how it should be used;
  • Modelling the use of the strategy which includes “thinking aloud” as the strategy is modelled;
  • Scaffolding learners to enable them to use the strategy with gradually increasing independence;
  • Having learners articulate what they are doing as they use the strategy;

Encouraging learners to apply the strategy as they read a range of texts and reflect on what they are doing. Teaching tips and strategies are set out on the Summarising Matrix.

At the higher levels, we can move into reciprocal teaching.

 

Janet & Naomi – Selecting Texts for the Wider Reading Programme

We need to cover the normal components of a reading programme, including independent reading, buddy reading or tuakana/teina,  reading with/guided reading,  and reading to. Reading aloud to our students is important to make difficult text accessible and model good reading strategies. Without having to focus on decoding, students can relax and take in more of the information. It also models the value and interest in reading.

We had a look at a transcript of a teacher leading a shared reading session with a learning objective of summarising. This was great modelling and well-scaffolded, where the whole class does the summarising for the first section, worked with a buddy and checked against the teacher’s model for the second section, and then did the third section independently.

The Reading Apprenticeship model is an approach to close reading, which is a strategy to model, scaffold, and gradually release agency to the learners. It uses unseen, unfamiliar texts so that students learn the skills to be able to read and unpack text independently. It is an active, rather than a passive process.

Reading Apprenticeship Core Routines are:

  • Think Aloud
  • Talking to the Text
  • Using a Metacognitive Bookmark
  • Problem Solving 

 

Kiri – Pulling it All Together

Our key elements for today have been:

  • Choosing appropriate texts
  • Grouping and selecting texts
  • Planning and compiling text sets
  • Texts for the wider reading programme

 

Reflections on Day 3

One thing I enjoyed about today was being able to connect to my prior knowledge of the T-Shaped Literacy model and see how that fits into planning my reading programme in Year 10 Humanities. I can see how what I am already doing, in terms of chosing a wide variety of texts and text types, can be extended by tailoring text choices to levelled reading groups. I need to explore the different resources available for curriculum levels 3 and 4, to become more familiar with them. I also want to look at using ChatGPT to provide different level versions of the same text. I am still not convinced I have found the right text for my introduction to the Holocaust unit, and I will keep hunting. I have found at least one non-fiction text on Epic which might be suitable, as well as the journal article I need to locate.

I have been pleasantly reassured that, despite not having taught guided reading formally for a long time, I do actually remember the principles and what to do!

What I will take back to my Faculty team are aspects like a reminder of the T-Shaped Literacy planning for diverse text types and some of the resources available to use to find texts for that. I would like to share the text coverage document with the team and see if we can map our planning against it and whether that identifies any gaps we should look at for our Semester 2 course planning.

In terms of what to share with my students, I will keep them updated on the guided reading programme as I plan and begin to implement this, so they understand what we are doing and why, and how it is helping them build their literacy skills.

Read more

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress.com. Theme: Baskerville 2 by Anders Noren.

Up ↑