Follow-up from RPI Day 4: Further professional reading

I followed up on some of the further reading resources provided on Day 4 of the RPI course.

Prior Knowledge – from Shanahan on Literacy 

Dr Timothy Shanahan points out that activating prior knowledge can be a double-edged sword: it may help students to process new information, or it may activate incorrect pre-conceptions which they will cling to and therefore not absorb new, contradictory information. In this blog post, he suggests ten guidelines for dealing with prior knowledge:

  1. Don’t overdo it.
  2. Respect the reader-text relationship.
  3. Don’t be afraid to fill students in on some “appropriate” background information.
  4. Excerpts are special.
  5. Use multiple readings to solve the prior knowledge problems.
  6. Culturally different students may benefit from a different prior knowledge input.
  7. Only deal with prior knowledge if it is likely to raise a comprehension problem.
  8. Prior knowledge issues can be addressed during and after reading.
  9. Do not focus on prior knowledge for texts that present information that will challenge
    readers’ current concepts.
  10. Analogies are a powerful way to bring prior knowledge to bear on a text.

Reflection: These can be summed up by saying that we should activate the minimum prior knowledge which is relevant to helping students understand the text, without issuing a bunch of ‘spoilers’ which will reduce the student’s agency in discovering and making meaning from the text. If we suspect that the prior knowledge may be incorrect and will be contradicted by the text, it is better NOT to activate it, since it will just reinforce the incorrect information. Not all background knowledge should be given before reading; sometimes it is more useful to interrupt the reading to give the information during reading.

I previously posted the following:

“The movie I am showing next week counts as a text to build background and prior knowledge. I have already set up a reflection/create/share activity for students to complete after viewing, but I am now going to go back and think about how to set a clearer purpose for viewing – e.g. whether to share the reflection questions with them before we view the film.”

Interestingly, after reading the above article I changed my mind about setting a purpose for viewing and sharing the reflection questions before students viewed the film – I decided it would narrow their responses to what they were seeing. Instead, I decided not to try and activate prior knowledge before the class watched Schindler’s List, and I think that was a good decision. I gave a minimal amount of background instead, explaining that the film was about someone who started out to exploit and make money from the Jews during the Holocaust, and then he ended up changing.

 

Activating Prior Knowledge – from Teaching Reading for Understanding in Years 4-8 – Wilson, Meiklejohn-Whiu, Wilkinson, Weiwei, Zhang and Zhoa

1. Activating Prior Knowledge Is Essential—but Needs to Be Relevant and Accurate

Students understand texts better when their relevant prior knowledge is activated. Inaccurate or irrelevant prior knowledge can hinder comprehension. Teachers need to help students focus on the right background knowledge—what’s central to understanding the main idea or deep structure of the text (e.g., trigonometry, not the ski field setting of a maths problem).

2. Background Knowledge Needs to Be Built, Not Just Activated

Not all students come to school with equal background knowledge, especially regarding cultural or domain-specific content. Building background knowledge includes:

  • Topic knowledge (specific subject of the text)
  • Domain knowledge (broader area it fits into)
  • Cultural knowledge (from students’ home and community)
  • General world knowledge.

3. Cultural Relevance Boosts Comprehension and Confidence

Students perform better and feel more confident when reading culturally familiar texts. Using culturally responsive texts can reframe struggling readers as capable, competent readers.

4. Effective Reading Instruction Connects Prior Knowledge to Inference-Making

Good practice involves supporting students to use their background knowledge actively (e.g., graphic organizers that combine “knowledge from the reader” + “knowledge from the text” → inference). This helps with higher-order comprehension tasks, not just recall.

5. Building Knowledge Also Supports Vocabulary and Strategy Use

Familiar topics allow students to focus cognitive energy on learning new vocabulary and comprehension strategies. For example, struggling readers with strong knowledge of baseball learned comprehension strategies more effectively when the texts were about baseball.

6. Teach Reading in Conceptually Integrated Units

Reading instruction is more powerful when embedded in rich, knowledge-building units, not isolated skill drills. Students should read multiple connected texts about the same topic to reinforce and deepen understanding.

7. Digital Reading Requires Digital Literacy

Prior topic knowledge is less crucial for online reading than for print; digital navigation skills become key. Students need to be taught how to use online tools (e.g., search engines) to build background knowledge on the fly.

Instructional Implications

  • Select texts carefully: Choose materials that build and draw on relevant knowledge, including cultural knowledge.
  • Frontload knowledge: Provide background before reading through discussion, visuals, or mini-lessons.
  • Support inference-making: Use tools like graphic organizers to guide the integration of prior knowledge and new information.
  • Use connected text sets: Design thematic units to build cumulative understanding.
  • Incorporate digital literacy: Especially when students are researching or reading online, teach them how to access and evaluate information.

Reflection: Thinking about this article in the context of my Night unit, I am deliberately not using culturally-connected texts, because the unit is teaching about human rights and the Holocaust. Therefore, I need to build background knowledge, which I have done through short videos on Judaism, showing a documentary about the Holocaust, reading an online article about the Righteous Among the Nations, and viewing the film Schindler’s List.

The class has now started reading the main text, Elie Wiesel’s Holocaust memoir, Night. Alongside this text, I am continuing to include complementary texts to build on the background knowledge and explore the relevance of these issues today. This coming week, I will use a journal article, Buttons by Iona McNaughton, to look at how students from a Jewish school in NZ remembered the Holocaust. This is from a Part IV journal, which means it is at the instructional level for my lowest ability reading group, and easily accessible by the rest of the class, who are all working at curriculum level 5.

I will try and see if I can find some NZ articles about human rights in a Māori context to make connections later in the unit which are culturally relevant.

 

Teaching Oral Fluency to Older Students – from Shanahan on Literacy

Oral fluency is not just for young or remedial readers—it supports reading comprehension in students from Year 4 upwards, including secondary students. Many older students struggle to apply decoding knowledge fluently; fluency instruction helps consolidate this.

Reading fluency includes:

  • Accuracy – reading the actual words on the page
  • Automaticity – reading without effort (usually measured by speed)
  • Prosody – reading with appropriate expression and phrasing

Poor fluency (e.g., slow or hesitant reading) negatively affects comprehension, especially in content-heavy subjects.

Practical Teaching Strategies

1. Paired Reading

  • Students take turns reading aloud and giving feedback.
  • Link to comprehension by asking students to identify main ideas or form questions after each section.

2. Repeated Reading

  • Students reread a short passage multiple times with feedback until they reach:
    • ~99% accuracy
    • 100 words per minute
    • Expressive, meaningful reading
  • This is great for content-area texts (e.g., science, social studies).

3. Pause, Prompt, Praise

  • Partners wait before correcting, offer prompts when needed, and praise accurate or improved reading.

4. Recorded Readings

  • Students record themselves reading.
  • Encourages practice and self-monitoring;
  • Teachers can spot check performance.

5. Chunking

  • Provide texts marked with phrase/sentence boundaries.
  • Helps with expression and understanding.
  • Students can later identify phrasing themselves.

Key Considerations

  • Not all students need fluency instruction. Focus on those reading below grade-level fluency (e.g., <150 WCPM in secondary).
  • Avoid performance-based oral reading (like round robin); use practice-focused activities.
  • Include fluency work in content areas (e.g., science, maths) to support comprehension of technical texts.
  • Just 10–30 minutes per week across subjects can make a meaningful difference.

 

Reflection: The more I think about practicing reading fluency, the more I remember my own personal experience as a teenager. I have a sister about 4 years younger than me, who is mildly dyslexic. As a child, she didn’t like reading and at some stage when I was around 15 or so, I decided to get her interested in books by reading to her. I can report that this was highly successful, and that we read our way through Moomintrolls, Narnia and the whole of Middle Earth, amongst other things. As an adult, she is still a keen reader and recommends books to me.

But the reading had an effect on me, too. I was conscious of becoming a better reader the more I practiced. I listened to my own voice and tried to make it sound ‘better’. I worked hard at phrasing and intonation. I began to try and do different voices for different characters. I was a really fluent reader before I started reading aloud to my sister, but I am sure I was a much more fluent reader when I had been doing it for a while. So, while I was a bit startled to read about the importance of high school students reading aloud and practising fluency, it resonated with my own personal experience, and makes a lot of sense to me.

During this process of reading aloud to my sister and consciously trying to get better at it over time, I was aware of my reading role model (my mother, Prue Wilson, an experienced primary and English teacher with an ATCL in Speech). As I read, I would have in my mind how my mum would have read it to us. So again, this points to the importance of me reading aloud to my classes, to provide them with the role model to imitate.

 

Explicit Teaching Strategies to Strengthen Reading across Learning Areas – MoE

This is a Ministry of Education professional development presentation which aims to help teachers:

1. Explore how explicit instruction supports ākonga development of six reading strategies.
2. Examine activities that can support the explicit instruction of reading strategies in your learning area.
3. Plan reading strategies that you can use with ākonga before, during and after engaging with a text.

Six Reading Strategies

Independent readers have six key strategies that help them become better readers and develop a stronger and deeper comprehension of a text:

1. Making connections
2. Monitoring
3. Visualising
4. Inferring
5. Questioning
6. Summarising

Explicit Instruction to Support the Six Reading Strategies

Explicit instruction helps make these six strategies visible in the classroom. Explicit instruction involves making students aware of the thinking processes independent readers use as they engage with text. (Metacognition) By supporting students with this metacognitive understanding, they can begin to actively transfer these reading skills across learning environments.

Before Reading

Before reading a text, there are a number of metacognitive strategies students can use to be more aware of what they are about to read and to support their engagement with the text. Key strategies are:

• Making Connections
• Pre-teaching of Vocabulary

Explicit pre-teaching of vocabulary and helping students make connections are the two key pre-reading activities. Connections include text to self, text to text, and text to world. (Techniques: Hot Potato, Word Maps.)

 

During Reading

While reading a text, there are a number of metacognitive strategies students can use to be more aware of what they are reading and to deepen their understanding of the text. Key strategies are:

• Visualising – Visualising is the act of making ‘mental images’ as you read. These mental pictures help readers to create meaning, to check for sense and to access greater understanding of the text. Explicit instruction to visualise can support ākonga to recall information and feel connected to the text. (Technique: Freeze Frame.)

• Inferring – When students infer, they find clues in the text and use what they already know from
personal experience or past knowledge to fully understand what the text is about. Independent readers can read “between the lines” to make predictions, revise these, understand underlying themes, hypothesise, make critical judgments, and draw conclusions.

But — before students can infer, they have to be explicitly taught how. Inferential thinking is a complex skill that develops over time and with experience. Teachers can help students to make inferences by asking inferential questions during shared reading or during discussion in guided reading. Alternatively, teachers may pause, when reading a text with students, to draw out clues from the text and prompt the students to make connections between different parts of the text in order to reach a conclusion. (Techniques: Inference Graphic Organisers, Inference with Pictures).

• Questioning – teaches students to be aware of what they do understand, identify what they do not understand, identify where to use appropriate strategies to resolve problems in comprehension. (Technique: teacher and peer questioning.)

 

After Reading

After reading a text, there are strategies that allow students to reflect and share what they’ve learnt. The strategies tend to be interactive so that students learn from each other. A key strategy is:

• Summarising – Summarising is being able to identify the most important ideas in a text, ignore the irrelevant information, and condense the central ideas in a way that makes sense to the learner. Teaching students to summarize improves their memory for what they read and acts as a check for comprehension. When using this strategy with learners, it is important to remember that summarising academic learning doesn’t come automatically.
• Using think-alouds helps make this process visible to ākonga.
• Kaiako need to provide ākonga with a variety of approaches to use as they learn to summarise. (Techniques: cooperative reading, collaborative poster, 3 level reading guides – on the lines, between the lines, beyond the text.)

 

Think Aloud  Supports all Reading Strategies

Independent readers recognise when there is a breakdown in their understanding of a text and independently deploy strategies to repair this. Developing readers need support to deliberately implement these strategies. By explicitly naming and modelling these strategies, kaiako can give all readers the tools they need to monitor and repair their understanding of a text.

Think Aloud supports ākonga to:
• be aware of what they do understand
• identify what they do not understand
• use appropriate strategies to resolve problems in comprehension

With this strategy, teachers verbalize aloud while reading a selection orally. Their verbalizations include describing things they’re doing as they read to monitor their comprehension. The purpose of the think-aloud strategy is to model for students how skilled readers construct meaning from a text.

(Techniques to support: Metacognitive Bookmarks.)

 

Reflection: This slide show is a really indepth and useful resource which I think I would like to use in literacy PD for all staff across the college, not just for the Humanities Faculty. I am going to look at building it into our literacy and numeracy PD in term 3.

For my own practice, I am going to print and laminate some of the metacognitive bookmarks for use with my reading groups. I won’t try and use these this week, instead, I am going to start using some of the terminology through my own think alouds with the groups. The article we are reading this week is a long one, so I think trying to introduce another new routine would cause information overload. 

I also liked the graphic organiser model for teaching inference and will look out for an appropriate text to use to introduce that.

Read more

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress.com. Theme: Baskerville 2 by Anders Noren.

Up ↑