Redefining Success
Bill Lucas – Rethinking Assessment
Is hugely impressed at the revolution quietly taking place in NZ. A readjustment is needed in how we think about education for young people. “The tail is far too waggy for an ill-fitting dog.”
He sees change as accelerating rapidly, partly because of AI. Our understanding of curriculum and pedagogy hasn’t quite caught up with this, and/or policy makers have not quite caught up with us.
He argued that there are seven things which we could do to improve assessment:
- Going back to the true purpose of assessment (i.e. formative)
- Building school-wide teacher capability
There is a curriculum and assessment underway now in the UK, and Bill is optimistic that there may be changes in the right direction.
Digital learner profile – strength-based, acknowledges that some courses are short courses, project-based inquiry learning, micro credentials – it is being rolled out in schools in Scotland right now. There is also great work happening in South Australia and Victoria.
They are working on a ‘skill builder’ – this looks very similar to the NPDL model – key competencies.
We need to move away from the idea that the only way of constructing a timetable is by subject disciplines.
Professor Sandra Milligan – University of Melbourne
She has been working with a wide range of schools who had been working on changing curriculum but who found the metrics were inhibiting them. They have been working on micro-credentialling which is accepted by the universities.
What is success? Curriculum supporting humans to thrive. You need to have a sense of competence. You need a sense of belonging. And finally, you need to have autonomy to act on your own or community purpose.
The old model: school as a place where students go to watch adults work. We need to learner agency, where students have the skill and ability to manage their own learning.
Young people need to really develop the human skills – not compete with AI.
The idea of reporting is profiles of student strengths, based on robust assessments, not on a grade or a score.
Sarah Martin – Stonefields School (EdTalks)
What might a mana-enhancing and strength-based assessment system look like? We set out to measure what we valued. e.g. our kotahi whanau tool, which specifically measures whanau engagement.
We also want to know how challenged and engaged our learners are – using a sliding scale to ask students about both. We also want to know if our design for learning is increasing student agency. They also use surveys, with all the metrics feeding into a dashboard. This year that dream has materialised.
Building a culture of improvement and encouraging teachers to be deeply reflective in their practice.
We need to reunite assessment with teaching and learning – not make it some separate event. Using AI for teacher efficiency.
What do you value in your context? How do you measure what you value? Is it underpinned by the premise ‘do no harm’?
In our table discussion on this section, we talked about the need for system-wide acceptance of new ways of assessing, and also the need for student agency in self-assessment and in building a portfolio of evidence of their skills.
Student Perspectives
Students from Stonefields, ASHS, Hobsonville Point
This was an amazing panel of young people from both primary and secondary schools. They were articulate and thoughtful, and we really appreciated them coming out in their school holidays to speak to us!
1. School Experience & Engagement
- Students highlighted the importance of social interaction, collaboration, and mature learning environments.
- Fun and engaging school experiences were associated with passionate and supportive teachers.
- 100-minute periods were preferred by some students as they allowed deeper learning compared to shorter class periods.
- Impact projects and presentations allowed students to express themselves, explore culture, and work collaboratively on community-related issues.
- Students valued supportive teachers who were approachable and were interested in their well-being beyond academic work.
2. Support Structures in School
- Students described “student classes” and teacher-student relationships that provide ongoing support.
- Open communication with teachers helped students address learning challenges and succeed academically.
- Individual feedback on portfolio-based subjects was appreciated.
3. Characteristics of a Good Teacher
- Interest in student well-being, enthusiasm, passion for subjects, approachability, trust, and the ability to make learning engaging.
- Teachers who helped build confidence, provided reassurance when students made mistakes, and explained concepts clearly were preferred.
- Personal relationships that extended beyond academics were highly valued.
4. Preparation for the Future
- Schools emphasized collaboration, self-management, and adaptability.
- Flexibility in subject choices allowed students to pursue areas of personal interest and career goals.
- “Adulting sessions” helped prepare students for life skills.
- Leadership roles within schools contributed to skill development.
- Students recognized the importance of being prepared for an unpredictable future.
5. Hopes for the Future
- Students desired a sustainable, green world with preserved habitats and cleaner environments.
- A world characterized by fairness, kindness, and peace was a common vision.
- They hoped for a society focused more on people than money, with greater environmental awareness and social justice.
- Peace and avoidance of war were of significant concern.
6. Concerns and Worries About the Future
- Worries about AI and technology impacting job security, possibly making some careers obsolete.
- Concern about climate change effects, endangered species, and environmental degradation.
- Fears of global conflicts or wars affecting New Zealand and the world.
- Social challenges including bullying and the need for improved mental and emotional support.
- The impact of insufficient political engagement among peers and limited awareness of how young people can effect change.
7. Communication and Family Involvement
- Use of apps and online platforms like Hero allowed parents to monitor student progress.
- Student-led conferences and in-school events helped bridge communication between students, teachers, and families.
- Some students found it easier to share experiences with parents or teachers when there was mutual trust and understanding.
- Others felt less comfortable sharing personal or academic details due to differences in interests or fear of judgment.
8. Educational Approaches and Skills Development
- Students agreed that modern education should focus more on broader, transferable skills beyond traditional academic subjects.
- Critical thinking, collaboration, empathy, entrepreneurship, and other contemporary skills were recognized as important.
- Impact projects and flexible subject choices supported personal growth and skill development.
- Some students felt their schools provided good opportunities for these skills, while acknowledging room for improvement.
- Free time and breaks during school days were seen as valuable for personal development and well-being.
Suggestions & Improvement Ideas
- Increase physical education classes with more structured activities like dodgeball.
- Reduce social pressures such as bullying related to social media abstinence.
- Start teaching social skills and environmental responsibility from a younger age.
- Improve student engagement in political and social issues by educating on how individuals can make a difference.
- Greater teacher involvement in individual student progress across all subjects.
- More practical and relatable learning about community and world issues.
Leading for Transformation
Martin Westwell – CE, South Australia Dept. Ed
The first thing is to really listen to people – have a shared aspiration and understand what you have to work with. Public Education forums: what we heard was student wanted to be more hands on, have more creativity, greater agency, etc.
Know your capabilities – your capacity for change.
Martin emphasized the importance of making choices in educational strategy and resisting rhetoric to focus on purposeful action. He shared insights on listening to stakeholders (students, teachers, families) to understand their aspirations and influence educational practices. Engaged over 1,000 students and communities in diverse forums.
Student voice and community evidence is crucial in influencing teachers and educational policy over traditional political and bureaucratic influences. Martin advocated for leadership that balances being tight on purpose yet flexible in execution, promoting shared accountability, professional responsibility, and empowerment across the system.
He addressed inclusion by discussing collaborations with Indigenous communities, with agreements to ensure cultural respect and mutual influence.
We need to focus on improving learning rather than just data, supporting equity, excellence, and wellbeing as interconnected goals. Martin stressed the role of professional identity and trust in educational leadership and the necessity for coherence across the system.
Dr George Philhower – Superintendent, Eastern Hancock Schools, Indiana
As change leaders, we can hear the music, but the people we are leading can only hear the tapping.
Beliefs, practices, teachers, structures & schools. If I want teachers to change their practice on a permanent basis, then I have to shift their beliefs. I need to give them some hints as to what tune is in my head that I am tapping to.
Joy – the idea that we have to be intentionally making it a place that students want to be. We try to embed magical moments for kids as often as we can.
Three promises: connection – know the kids; we try to create an environment that feels like home – safe; growth ; success – we want kids to be excited about what happens after graduation.
Collaborating with other schools that are using a similar approach.
Advocated for a culture of joy as a foundational aspect of transformational change. Examples include interactive celebrations such as birthday parties for every student and music/dance rituals to create a lively, engaging school environment.
Introduced the concept of a “four-chord song” to symbolize a simple yet powerful set of core values that guide the district:
- Joy – intentionally foster joy daily in schools.
- Connection – knowing students personally, including their strengths and aspirations.
- Growth – ensuring students learn new and memorable things every day.
- Success – preparing students for life after graduation beyond academic proficiency.
Shared practice innovations such as hiring celebrations, therapy dogs in schools, and having a Joy Integration Specialist to support teachers in embedding joy into lessons.
Discussed launching a network of publicly funded micro-schools allowing innovative, flexible education models featuring multi-age classrooms and self-paced learning, a first in Indiana.
Emphasized the importance of shifting from positional leadership to belief-driven leadership for lasting transformational change.
Dale Bailey – Springboard Trust
We believe in strategic leadership at the school level and we are optimistic about the possibilities. They have worked with over 800 schools across the country.
Key points for transforming:
- Curiosity: avoid group think, look for the evidence, form an hypothesis, not an opinion. Ask what we are missing, what do we need to validate.
- Bring the outside in: have wide conversations across boundaries. Ask who is silent, who is absent in our conversation. Build new coalitions, seek out student voice.
- Simplify the goals: less is more, focus on the most important, where we can make a difference. Ask what will be the keys that will unlock more positive change.
- Evidence for progress: measure with absolute integrity what you want to shift. Discuss and challenge the evidence, share the progress.
Dale highlighted the challenges and hopes of New Zealand’s education system, focusing on the need for curiosity, bringing external perspectives into education, and simplifying goals. He emphasized the moral imperative for educational transformation and the importance of measuring progress with integrity, and noted the influence of diverse volunteers in education leadership, helping schools learn from other sectors.
Advocated for clear, purpose-driven leadership backed by strong values and community-agreed principles. Discussed the importance of manageable goals and evidence-based progress measurement, including use of modern data visualization. Reinforced that performative politics have limits and authentic leadership requires deep community engagement and shared responsibility.
Maurie Abraham – former Principal, Hobsonville Point Secondary School – How might we lead?
We need to ‘know our why’:
- Why? – core values and beliefs e.g. student at the centre
- How? – principles, guidelines for action e.g. look for ways to align learning to students’ interests and needs
- What? – practices
Maurie talked about the journey of Hobsonville Point High School.
Vision: To create a stimulating, inclusive learning environment which empowers learners to contribute confidently and responsibly in our changing world.
They wanted to ensure two pathways of Excellence, both Academic and Personal – they came up with the ‘Hobsonville Habits’.
Principles: Innovate through personalised learning, engage through powerful partnerships; inspire through deep challenge and inquiry.
At Hobsonville Point they transformed school assessment and recognition by focusing on values such as inquiry, collaboration, innovation, and connection rather than solely academic results. They emphasized engagement through authentic partnerships and inquiry-based learning, shifting away from traditional ‘credit chasing’.
Maurie highlighted the creation of a school culture where personal excellence is publicly recognized, empowering all students regardless of academic standing.
Where to from here? Panel Session: Anthony Mackay, Virgel Hammonds, Jeff Wetzler
1. Tony Mackay: Four Big Shifts for Education Transformation
- Establish a shared, purpose-driven system focusing on education for human flourishing that integrates care for self, others, the planet, economic prosperity, social cohesion, and wellbeing.
- Broaden the concept of learning by redefining success, expanding recognition of various forms of learning, and integrating cognitive, social, and emotional learning for holistic human development.
- Redesign the education profession and learning environment by collaborating with allied professionals and supporting formal, non-formal, and informal learning in diverse settings.
- Reimagine pathways and governance particularly focusing on the senior years of secondary education to create multiple, career-connected pathways aligned to workforce needs and a governance model closely attuned to learning rather than traditional government structures.
- Emphasized the importance of place-based learning that respects and embraces contextual diversity.
2. Virgel Hammonds: Collaboration, Community-Driven Innovation, and Inclusion
- Highlighted the need for collaboration and convening innovators, educators, researchers, policymakers, community members, and learners to redesign learning systems.
- Announced the merger of Aurora Institute with the Learning Accelerator, aiming to strengthen and scale innovation through unified leadership and distributed models.
- Stressed the importance of including young people, families, communities, and workforce partners in co-designing learning experiences.
- Encouraged reimagining credit and credential systems to include alternative competencies relevant to workforce and community needs.
- Advocated for hyper-inclusive, learner-centered approaches that use diverse data and metrics to ensure equitable outcomes.
- Reinforced that policy and regulation must be informed by actual practices on the ground and invites stakeholders to experience what transformed learning looks like.
3. Jeff Wetzler: Strength-Based Approaches, Learner Experiences, and Leadership
“There’s nothing wrong with us that can’t be fixed by what’s right with us.” – Bill Clinton
- Advocated for building on existing strengths and assets in schools and communities.
- Emphasized centering on learner experiences as an essential measure, beyond just learning outcomes. Suggested actively listening to and engaging young people to gain valuable insights.
- Promoted community-based design, meaning education cannot evolve in isolation but needs partnerships across schools, healthcare, housing, transportation, and more.
- Encouraged looking at existing successful models nationally and globally to accelerate transformation.
- Highlighted the critical role of learner-centered leadership that prioritizes what is best for learners, even if it means dismantling legacy systems.
Table Discussion
The aim: every learner thriving and a system that supports them. We need to make sure it is not just a micro-movement.
Don’t disregard the curriculum work which was done before the current government. Have we clearly identified what from the current structures we are going to leave behind.
Where are the businesses, the arts community, the other voices at this conference?
Within the constraints of the changed curriculum, there is still capacity for us as educators to make the learning relevant and appropriate.
We begin with the learner at the centre. We need a visioning process for future learning – is it a re-evolution, or a revolution? It needs to include the range of voices, including iwi, all akonga, teachers, leaders, whanau, wider community, health providers, social workers, businesses.
Go to listen. Find the people who are interested, and invite them to be part of the process.
We need a starting point – e.g. the EdRising draft. An iterative process in which we share models and possibilities and get feedback. Use scenarios to help people visualise the possibilities.
Derek Wenmoth – Closing Remarks
Overview
The gathering centered on visionary discussions about the future of education, focusing on aligning purpose and vision across organizations, the role of policy, systemic leadership, and transformative approaches to schooling. Various speakers contributed insights into collaboration, educational frameworks, policy influence, and the importance of indigenous perspectives in education reform.
Key Themes and Discussions
1. Aligning Purpose and Vision
- Emphasis on collaboration among organizations to align purpose and vision.
- Sharing of ideas around youth ambition and educational engagement.
- Highlighted the importance of a shared framework for interviews and data collection to underpin educational work.
2. Policy and Systemic Leadership
- Participants highlighted the necessity of being agents of policy development rather than merely advocates or complainers.
- Schools and educators are positioned as leaders within the education system.
- Understanding the system’s elements (learner, qualifications framework, organizational delivery, learning culture, curriculum) is crucial for effective leadership.
- Discussions of current educational policies, including concerns about the Education and Training Amendment Act and its implications.
3. Educational Ecosystem and Community Involvement
- Recognition that learning happens both inside and outside school settings (formal, semi-formal learning).
- Community and business involvement is essential for enriching education and contributing to society.
- Examples provided about community protests and business partnership roles.
4. Horizon-Free Schools and Educational Transformation
- Identification of three horizons in education:
- Horizon One: Current post-industrial school model with traditional classes, timetables, and subjects.
- Horizon Two: Disruptive innovations focusing on new pedagogies, open spaces, and competencies, which face implementation challenges.
- Horizon Three: Visionary future state where transformative, ecosystem-oriented schools exist.
- Emphasis on preserving valuable aspects from existing systems while embracing innovation.
- The concept of “sigmoid carbide” to sustain new innovations and move education forward.
- The meeting called for collective action to design and implement horizon-free schools.
5. Collaboration and Community Building
- Proposal to build a large, collaborative network, possibly including thousands of participants from various sectors.
- Plans for ongoing online discussions and convenings (monthly or every five weeks).
- Identification of experts and future leaders who could contribute to ongoing efforts, e.g., an Australian principal with a PhD in educational futures involved with OECD.
- Engagement with organizations such as ATC and AEC for collaborative synergy.
- Invitation extended to participants to join and contribute actively.
6. Engagement and Next Steps
- Participants encouraged to reflect on their actions moving forward through a provided personal challenge sheet.
- Collection of feedback and ongoing dialogue through digital platforms.
- The formation of a think tank and vision team to facilitate future work.
- Possibility of large-scale conferences and gatherings to sustain momentum.
- Commitment to follow up with participants and expand the network.
Hana O’Regan
- Mihi to Derek for his vision in drawing us all together.
- strong emphasis on the importance of indigenous knowledge and perspectives.
- A call to develop educational solutions rooted in the local context of Aotearoa New Zealand.
- Embracing Te Tiriti o Waitangi (Treaty of Waitangi) as central to creating a uniquely Aotearoa education system.
- Encouragement to create a system “more like ourselves” rather than assimilating colonizer practices.